White clapboard porch with a black front door, arched transom, shuttered window and a potted fern.

The Hammel House Rejoins a Main Street That Learned to Draw Crowds Without It

  • October 29, 2026

There are five guest rooms upstairs at 121 S. Main St., each named for a bird: Peacock, Cardinal, Goldfinch, Hummingbird and Bluebird. The new owners have been furnishing them with period antiques bought from shops and estate sales around Waynesville. Those rooms can be booked again. The rest of the Hammel House Inn is still being rebuilt.

This is the first holiday season since 2024 with the inn's lights on, and Main Street has changed since then. While the building sat closed, the merchants started an event of their own, and last year it drew more people than almost anything on the village calendar. From early November to early December, the reopened inn and the event built in its absence will be on the same street for the first time.

What two closed years meant for Main Street

In August 2024, a fire started in the kitchen area at the back of the inn after its suppression system failed. The kitchen was gutted, and smoke damaged the inn itself. Dayton 24/7 Now reported in March that the historic building itself escaped fire damage. The kitchen addition, though, was considered beyond rebuilding, and weather did more damage over the next 18 months.

Lacie Sims, executive director of the Waynesville Area Chamber of Commerce, described the effect on the shops nearby to Dayton 24/7 Now:

"It had a dramatic impact on our business community. Some of our shops lost 50% of their sales. So when this building came up for auction and Jeff bought it, we were ecstatic."

A 204-year-old tavern drew enough people to Main Street that losing it cut into the sales of shops that sell nothing like what it sold. In the same story, Sims said shops nearby started doing better as soon as the inn announced its reopening plans, simply because people stopped by to look.

What is open now, and what waits until spring

The Dayton Daily News reported that father and daughter Jeff Bonham and Allison Edmonds and their family bought the inn at auction at the end of August. Their goal is to restore it to its 19th-century appearance. Bonham told the paper, "I didn't buy it as just an investment. We want to be part of history." Bonham was one of the people behind Bonham Electric before he retired, and in the weeks after the auction, family, friends and contractors were cleaning, rewiring and redecorating the building.

Here is where the project stands this week:

  • The rooms. The Hammel House Inn website says rooms are available to rent now.
  • The restaurant. It is still under construction and closed. The owners expect to open it in spring 2027.
  • Parking. The Dayton Daily News reported that the village bought the lot next door and plans to tear down the structure on it to make a 20-space downtown parking lot. No completion date has been published.
  • The mural. That lot will leave the inn's old brick side wall facing the street. The owners have started a mural fundraiser for a painting of old Waynesville on that wall, with a goal of $25,000.

Village Manager Gary Copeland, who is also the director of public safety, told Dayton 24/7 Now that the renovation is "meeting all the codes actually exceeding them." Speaking as someone who reads old buildings for a living, I'd point out the sequence. Rooms first, then a new commercial kitchen and dining room on the footprint of an addition that could not be saved. That order makes sense when the most expensive and code-heavy part of the job is also the part the fire destroyed.

So this season, the Hammel House is back as a place to stay but not yet as a place to eat. Waynesville's holiday crowds will see the building lit and occupied, and its dining room will stay closed until spring.

The event the merchants built while the inn was closed

The fire was in August 2024. The first "A Day in Waynesville: Step into Stars Hollow" was held in 2025, while the inn was still shut, and organizers say it drew 20,000 visitors. According to the Dayton Daily News, the Waynesville Merchants Association and Taylor's Coffee and Creamery are sponsoring the event again this year.

This year it runs Nov. 21 and 22 on Main Street, listed by the county visitor bureau as Waynesville Town Square Days. The guests are two Gilmore Girls actors: Scott Patterson, who played Luke Danes, and Sean Gunn, who played Kirk Gleason. Julie Abel, a co-founder of Step Into Stars Hollow, told the paper the goal is to introduce "thousands of visitors to everything our historical small town has to offer."

What's free and what isn't:

Part of the weekend Cost
Walking Main Street, shopping, themed food and drinks, live music, costume contests Free general admission
Individual photo op or Q&A panel Listed at $80 plus fees
Autograph session Listed at $85 plus fees
Duo photo op with both actors Listed at $150 plus fees
Coffee with an actor Listed at $225 plus fees

Those prices come from the Ticketleap page and could change before the weekend. The posted hours also differ. The county listing says Saturday 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. and Sunday 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., while the ticketing page shows 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. If you plan to be downtown late on Saturday, check the hours first.

Five weeks on Main Street, in order

Organizers expect this year's Stars Hollow weekend to be bigger than last year's. Christmas in the Village follows two weekends later. For anyone who lives near Main, the order matters. Here is the calendar, starting this weekend:

  1. Saturday, Oct. 31, 6 to 8 p.m. Village-wide trick-or-treat. The downtown merchants held their own daytime trick-or-treat on Oct. 25.
  2. Nov. 6 to 8, Hearthwarming Holidays. Free. Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., Sunday noon to 5 p.m. Participating shops hand out recipe cards, so you collect them as you go from shop to shop. This is the quietest of the three downtown weekends and the best one for an unhurried look at the shops, including newer ones like Petal Vintage at 55 S. Main St., which opened in June.
  3. Saturday, Nov. 14, 3 to 11 p.m., Owl Fest. Held at the visitor center near the Caesar Creek dam, with live owl presentations by the Ohio School of Falconry, according to Ohio State Parks. It's the one event in these five weeks that isn't downtown.
  4. Nov. 21 and 22, Town Square Days and Step into Stars Hollow. Expect the biggest crowds of the season, based on last year's 20,000. That's also the weekend the Nature Center Association's Fall Cast Iron Cookout is at the Caesar Creek Nature Center on Nov. 21, and it was listed as sold out.
  5. Dec. 4 to 6, Christmas in the Village. Friday 1 to 9 p.m., with shops opening at 11 a.m. Saturday noon to 8 p.m. Sunday 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. On Friday and Saturday evenings, more than 1,000 luminaries line Main Street. Santa will be at the Main Street gazebo, there's a heated entertainment tent, and the Parade of Santas starts Sunday at 1 p.m.
  6. Sunday, Dec. 6, Waynesville Street Faire Christmas Market. Vendors, artisans, food trucks, live music and activities for kids. Its listing says it starts at 10 a.m., while the Chamber's Christmas in the Village page says 11 a.m.

Through all six, the closed restaurant at the Hammel House is the one gap on Main Street. Guests can sleep at the inn on the luminary weekend and wake up to the view Edmonds described to the Dayton Daily News: "Imagine waking up here and looking out seeing everything going on." For dinner, they'll go to the street's other restaurants. Two years ago, the inn's dining room would have taken some of those reservations.

The quieter evenings on either side

Around the big weekends, the Chamber has two smaller evening events on its calendar. Its Business to Business networking meets Nov. 19 at 5 p.m. at A Chick with Wicks, and Dec. 17 at 5 p.m. at Stonehouse Tavern for a Holiday Jingle Mingle. The December one comes after the last festival weekend, when Main Street is back to a normal crowd.

By spring 2027, if the restaurant opens on schedule, a parking lot is built next door and the mural fundraiser reaches its goal, the Hammel House will be back to everything it was before the fire. It will be the anchor that Sims said some shops lost half their sales without. And it will return to a Main Street that started a 20,000-visitor weekend while the inn was closed.

If you own an older building in or near downtown Waynesville and want to understand what a careful restoration involves, from planning around a fire-damaged addition to deciding which spaces to bring back first, I'm happy to walk through it with you. Wenzler Concierge Group can help you plan that kind of work. Schedule your complimentary concierge consultation.

Work With Us

We see the potential and heart in all homes and understand our clients passion for finding the home of their dreams. We love the process so much and we will be by your side, negotiating for you, to buy or sell your dreams. We look forward to working with you!

Follow Us on Instagram